With nearly 97% of New Jersey Medicaid beneficiaries enrolled in managed care, New Jersey hospitals have long relied on pre-authorizations by managed care organizations (MCOs) to ensure reimbursement for inpatient care. However, beginning several years ago, the state expanded the scope of its utilization review vendor’s contract to cover MCO encounter claims, and New Jersey hospitals are now increasingly facing an aggressive wave of retrospective audits of pre-authorized claims which challenge the MCO’s earlier determinations on medical necessity.
Hospitals are increasingly caught in a compliance blind spot – vulnerable to state recoupments on care, even when preauthorization was sought and received from the MCO responsible for paying the claim. As a result, several New Jersey hospitals have begun challenging the state’s authority to recover payments in these circumstances.
Before an Audit
To protect your institution’s revenue and withstand state scrutiny, hospital leadership and legal teams should take immediate, proactive steps:
Review Each MCO Agreement
New Jersey’s contracts with MCOs require the MCOs to include in their provider contracts provisions allowing the state’s utilization review vendor to audit inpatient claims and adjust claims after an adverse audit finding. Despite those requirements, some MCO provider agreements omit that language or contain payment protections for preauthorized admissions. The terms of the hospital’s own agreement can shape its response to a repayment demand.
Hospitals should closely review each of their MCO agreements, amendments, and any manuals incorporated by reference for provisions allowing the state’s vendor to review claims and/or seek repayment, protections for reimbursement of care the MCO preauthorized, and deadlines for appealing claims. They should flag any provisions which either explicitly authorize or conflict with the state’s alleged authority to audit and seek recoupment of claims that were preauthorized by the MCO.
Document Why Inpatient Care Was Necessary
Regardless of whether a claim was preauthorized, a patient’s chart should clearly document why the patient could not safely receive care under observation or outpatient status. The care team must document why inpatient care was necessary, how any new findings affected treatment, any alternatives that were considered or tried that would allow the patient to remain on outpatient status, and why they were deemed insufficient. Ensure that the clinical documentation supports both the level of care and the diagnosis-related group billed.
Keep Approvals With the Claim Record
Make sure utilization management and revenue cycle teams can retrieve the original authorization, any approvals for continued stays, and payment records for each claim.
After an Adverse Audit Finding
An adverse audit finding calls for a coordinated response that addresses both the clinical basis for the denial and the authority to recover payment.
Identify the Reviewer and the Deadline
Record when the notice arrives, which claims or days it covers, and the reason for the finding. If the finding comes through New Jersey Utilization Review, confirm the applicable appeal process and filing deadline. Also determine who is seeking repayment and whether future payments may be offset while the dispute is pending.
Assess the Authority to Reopen the Claim
Compare the authority cited in the notice with the applicable MCO agreement in effect when the care was delivered. Check whether the agreement includes the audit language the state requires MCOs to add and whether it protects payment for preauthorized admissions. If the agreement guarantees payment for preauthorized claims, a hospital may have a basis to challenge the repayment demand. Compare the criteria the auditor applied with those the MCO used to approve the admission, and document any differences. Preserve any objections while preparing the clinical appeal.
Respond to the Clinical Finding
Gather the MCO’s approvals, the auditor’s findings, and the relevant chart entries. Have utilization management and the treatment team explain why the admission and any disputed days of the stay were appropriate and met the applicable criteria. Address the reviewer’s specific reasons for concluding that a lower level of care would have been sufficient.
Verify What Is at Risk
Reconcile the repayment demand against the original payment and any amounts already withheld. Check whether the finding affects the entire admission or only certain days, and whether payment for outpatient or ancillary services remains available.
Pursue the Appropriate Appeal
Use the clinical record, contractual provisions, and amount at stake to determine which findings to contest. Submit the supporting evidence and objections within the applicable deadlines. Where matters cannot be resolved on first or second level appeals, ensure that a fair hearing before the Office of Administrative Law is requested in a timely manner.








